The Art and Power of Preaching with David Schlafer
The Art and Power of Preaching with David Schlafer
In this episode of Good News, Lynn Shematek and co-hosts Deacons Jon Shematek and Lauren Welch speak with Reverend Dr. David Schlafer—a philosopher, priest, preacher, and teacher. Dr. Schlafer shares his journey from a background in philosophy and Southern Baptist roots to becoming an influential Episcopal priest and educator in homiletics. He delves into his philosophy of preaching, the significance of developing one's unique voice, and the preaching role of deacons and laypersons in the church. The discussion is rich with insights on the importance of careful, respectful use of language in preaching and the transformative power of sermons. Listeners are encouraged to embrace deep listening and nurturing conversations as vital tools for meaningful and impactful preaching.
00:00 Introduction and Welcome
01:25 David Schlafer's Background and Journey
03:25 Philosophy and Preaching
04:51 Teaching and Influences
10:13 The Role of Deacons in Preaching
13:59 Engaging the Congregation
23:09 The Power of Language in Preaching
25:25 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
Dr. David J. Schlafer's email: drdavidjschlafer@gmail.com
Books (all 18 of them!) by the Rev. Dr. David J. Schlafer, including "Surviving the Sermon: A Guide to Preaching for Those Who Have to Listen" and "Your Way with God's Word" may be found at https://www.goodreads.com/author/list/141628.David_J_Schlafer and on Amazon books.
Audio version of this episode is available at podcast platforms linked to https://listening-for-clues.captivate.fm/listen
The Good News! podcast series is part of the ListeningforClues portfolio. Catch us at https://listeningforclues.com/
© 2025 Listening for Clues
Transcript
Oh
2
:Hello, friends.
3
:I'm Lynn Shematek with the Good News Team.
4
:Today let's meet the Reverend Dr.
5
:David Schlafer, philosopher,
priest, preacher, and teacher.
6
:Join our co-host Deacons Jon Shematek
and Lauren Welch as we bring you another
7
:episode of Good News, all about people
making a difference in the world.
8
:Jon Shematek: Welcome David
Schlafer to the podcast.
9
:Good News.
10
:We're really thrilled that
you're joining us today.
11
:Lauren Welch: We're really
happy to have you, David.
12
:We have waited for this
day for a long time.
13
:David Schlafer: it is a real joy for
me to connect with the two of you.
14
:I have the fondest memories over,
the span of, probably 15 years.
15
:Working with, deacons in the Deacon
Training school, helping them develop
16
:their preaching, and the two of you have
been, such rich and engaging colleagues.
17
:It's mighty fun to be back and having
seen several of these podcasts, it's a
18
:privilege and honor to join them really.
19
:Jon Shematek: Oh, thank you David.
20
:That's great.
21
:I've gotta say, Lauren and I were mentors
in the deacon formation program here
22
:when you were teaching to our students.
23
:But I learned more from
you about how to preach.
24
:you've been a guiding star for me
for so many years, and it's one
25
:of the things I really enjoy when
I get the chance to preach, here
26
:in Baltimore at the Cathedral.
27
:Thank you.
28
:tell us a bit about yourself, David,
and how you got to where you are today
29
:David Schlafer: In some ways, the
simplest, way to say who I am, what
30
:I do professionally, is to say that
in a previous vocational life, I
31
:went into philosophy because of bad
preaching and came into the teaching
32
:of preaching convinced that it doesn't
have to be bad or boring philosophy.
33
:To unpack that a little bit, I
am the son of a southern Baptist
34
:preacher who was himself born and
raised in New York, so not a typical.
35
:Southern Baptist preacher, he was
an exceedingly earnest preacher.
36
:Heavy on exegesis.
37
:Heavy on exhortation.
38
:Sincere and very boring.
39
:But every once in a while, into
town would ride an evangelist
40
:and we would have services every
night, Sunday through Saturday,
41
:unless it was a two week campaign.
42
:these.
43
:Evangelists would preach fire and
brimstone, which was terrifying and
44
:manipulating, and I really didn't want
to have very much to do with any of that.
45
:There's an additional dimension
here that may be worth, saying.
46
:my father, with an earned, theological,
doctorate degree, was very intelligent.
47
:But he had what, is sometimes
called a hermeneutic of assent.
48
:God said it.
49
:The Bible teaches it.
50
:I believe it.
51
:I want to understand and practice it.
52
:I came into life essentially with what's
called a hermeneutic of suspicion.
53
:Why should I believe it?
54
:The Bible says this here.
55
:It says that there, which
are you supposed to believe?
56
:there was this gentle clash
back and forth between us.
57
:When I went to college, my father insisted
that I go to a, strong Christian college.
58
:Which was Wheaton outside of Chicago.
59
:I went there kicking and screaming
because I really wanted to go to
60
:Northwestern and major in, pre-law.
61
:Wheaton was where I ended up.
62
:within the second, semester
of being there, I was in an
63
:introduction to philosophy course.
64
:The professor was absolutely
mesmerizing and, I found myself.
65
:trying to work my way toward faith.
66
:primarily by means of reason because
images and feelings had been so polluted
67
:in my background that I really didn't
want to have anything to do with them.
68
:But then, because of a change of job, we
started attending an Episcopal church.
69
:By this point I had read my
way into the necessity of a
70
:sacramental view of the universe.
71
:here was worship, which embodied that.
72
:and in which it was possible to
be, open to sense, open to emotion
73
:because it was not a manipulation
around the process of reason.
74
:Very early on, I, had the sense of,
wanting to be able to be behind the
75
:altar as a way of embodying for myself
the theology to which I had come
76
:My undergraduate teaching job dissolved
because, I had become an Episcopalian and,
77
:this college, was suspicious of those.
78
:So I ended up attending, Nashotah
House Episcopal Seminary and, very
79
:quickly, found myself, engaged
there, teaching in moral theology.
80
:I was invited to be part of a
beginning preaching class, and,
81
:found that I deeply loved it.
82
:very instrumental for me.
83
:is a, homiletics professor by the
name of Eugene Lowry, whose book
84
:"Doing Time in the Pulpit" made
a significant, impact upon me.
85
:suggesting that not all sermons are
stories, and yet, it is possible to
86
:shape a sermon in such a way that
it has a narrative quality to it.
87
:Taking.
88
:Listeners from a beginning point
on a journey, that leads, to
89
:some kind of fresh, recognition.
90
:that's the way I have, tried
to do my own preaching.
91
:It's the way I try to nurture people
who are studying preaching, with me.
92
:Which has been both in seminary classes,
in four different seminaries, in,
93
:preaching conferences here and in England
and Canada, in a fair degree of writing.
94
:And now what I'm spending most of my
professional time doing is coaching
95
:individual preachers some on a weekly
basis, some on an occasional basis, and
96
:some, back and forth with colleagues,
where we simply talk shop with each other.
97
:Jon Shematek: That's, quite, a journey
and you've published a number of,
98
:books on preaching that, I assume
people have actually read and are using
99
:some of the wisdom in those books.
100
:David Schlafer: the, topic of the first
one, pretty much says something about
101
:the background I just briefly described,
"Surviving the Sermon, a Guide to
102
:Preaching for Those Who Have to Listen."
103
:Preaching is primarily a listening
art You have to shape it in a way,
104
:that's different from, reading an
essay or looking at a still picture.
105
:You have to shape the sermon in a
way that takes people on the journey,
106
:that the interplay between the text.
107
:The congregation, and the culture,
and the time seemed to be leading.
108
:Lauren Welch: And David, one of the
books too, and I know that you always
109
:encouraged us to find our own voice.
110
:we don't have to preach like
David or Jon or whoever we have
111
:seen or heard in the past, but to
find our own voice, can you say.
112
:Something about that.
113
:David Schlafer: Yeah, I think the
book that, followed "Surviving
114
:the Sermon, a Guide to Preaching
for Those Who Have to Listen"
115
:is "Your Way with God's word, Discovering
Your Distinctive Preaching Voice", which,
116
:leads people through exercises, helping
them recognize the voice within them, and
117
:the voice that is in process of coming to
be clearer, fuller, richer, deeper, wider.
118
:so that has been a valuable insight
to preachers who, want to be faithful
119
:to the gospel, but realize that it's
not possible to do that unless you
120
:can do it in your particular way.
121
:Philip Brooks, the famous, Episcopal
preacher at Trinity, Church,
122
:Wall Street, , put it this way.
123
:preaching, he says, is truth through
personality, not the truth of personality
124
:or truth about personality, but the
truth of the gospel embodied in and
125
:through the personality of the preacher.
126
:Brooks went on to say, if
it were possible to preach.
127
:All the truths of the incarnation in
a disembodied way that would not be
128
:preaching the truth of the incarnation.
129
:So it's a matter of coming more
aware of what distinctive gifts,
130
:limitations, wounds that I may have,
all of which God can make, good use of.
131
:to do that in the service of the gospel,
you can make a case for saying that
132
:the whole of scripture, the texts on
which we base our sermons is a series.
133
:Conversations back and forth
between, the author and the people.
134
:In some ways, the scripture
is an anthology of sermons.
135
:What we do as preachers is pick
up on that conversation and
136
:carry it into, the present day.
137
:Jon Shematek: David, you mentioned,
elements that might be involved.
138
:You mentioned wounds in particular.
139
:I'm wondering, some people say that
one of the most powerful ways to preach
140
:is through your own vulnerability.
141
:Do you think that's or no?
142
:David Schlafer: that is if one understands
it correctly, to simply use the pulpit.
143
:As an excuse for venting or weeping
or raging or, engaging in self
144
:therapy, will not work at all.
145
:Okay?
146
:And yet, to be able to access the
dimensions of one's wounds, sometimes
147
:without even mentioning yourself at
all, but using images, metaphors,
148
:anecdotes, can be, profoundly effective.
149
:a Christian educator of a previous,
generation, put it, This way,
150
:the I of the preacher needs
to become the I of the sermon.
151
:The capital I of the preacher needs
to become the IEYE of the sermon.
152
:what you are attempting to do is
not draw attention to yourself.
153
:Rather present your experience
in a way that other people can,
154
:identify with, even though it will
not be exactly the same as yours,
155
:it will be a point of human contact.
156
:Lauren Welch: And David, you also were
very instrumental in, deacon formation
157
:programs in Maryland, and Virginia to help
deacons learn, that they are called to
158
:preaching too, because the church did not
always see deacons as called to preaching,
159
:but to serving and being a servant.
160
:David Schlafer: Sure I could speak to
that with a fair degree of passion.
161
:often when working with deacons, in the
process of training to be preachers,
162
:I say that even though I'm a priest,
I have a certain degree of Deacon
163
:Envy because, based on a study I had
access to some time ago, it seems to
164
:me that not only are deacons allowed to
preach, but that, the role of deacon.
165
:Is fundamental to understanding
what preaching is about.
166
:Often if, deacons are allowed to preach at
all, it is simply, whipping up enthusiasm
167
:for the current, outreach project.
168
:let's bring on the deacon to
say, you must, you ought, you
169
:should get involved in this.
170
:But, the fundamental
understanding of, the diaconate.
171
:This, book that I was given access
to goes something like this.
172
:The initial reading, of Deacon was
found not in Christian, writing, but
173
:in Greek mythology where Hermes was
Zeus's, deacon Hermes, the winged,
174
:creature, Zeus, the Chief God.
175
:Hermes was, not just the messenger
boy, so to speak, but, deacon
176
:meant to be attendant, someone
who is right, beside, the master,
177
:attendant, spokesperson, embodiment.
178
:And so when Hermes speaks,
that's really Zeus speaking.
179
:Hermes is the name from which the
discipline of hermeneutics is, derived.
180
:what a preaching deacon is primarily,
is a hermaneut, someone who bridges the
181
:gap between, culture, and, Christian
community helps, one, understand the other
182
:sheds light from one upon, the other.
183
:in the book of Acts, there is the,
appointing of the deacons, all of
184
:whom are Greeks, in a church trying
to incorporate and integrate,
185
:Greek widows with Jewish folks.
186
:The initial concern is the
widows are not getting fed.
187
:the implication in terms of, the study
I did is that what the deacon at really
188
:did was, sit at table with, the Greeks,
when, the apostles were preaching and,
189
:the eyes of the Greeks glazed over.
190
:What the deacons would do would be to say,
Hey, explain that in a d different way.
191
:facilitating, a back
and forth interaction.
192
:my sense, is that, the role of the deacon
is translating, interpreting, the biblical
193
:experience, and scripture text into a
world that, doesn't understand it often,
194
:doesn't want it, but can be illumined
by it what seems in culture alien, can
195
:to those of us who are in the church.
196
:shine fresh light, and add deeper
meaning to, what we say we believe.
197
:Jon Shematek: I don't think I've
ever heard such a, distilled.
198
:And totally accurate description of
how I understand the diaconate as well.
199
:I just wouldn't have guessed
that, preaching was the model
200
:for that to be, exemplified.
201
:That's great.
202
:there are a couple of things
that have popped into my.
203
:Head.
204
:David, one of the things I'm wondering
about for you personally, before we
205
:ask things that are maybe a little
more theoretical is, I definitely
206
:have the sense looking back over your
life, that you've been so engaged
207
:with preaching pretty much all along.
208
:can you talk a little bit about,
What you love about preaching?
209
:What is it that you love about
teaching preaching, which I
210
:guess are two different things?
211
:David Schlafer: I think
they're closely connected.
212
:What I love about preaching is, if
in fact it's done well, one moves
213
:from as, politician, Fred Craddock
put it the nod of recognition.
214
:quite so I understand that.
215
:Through the shock of recognition,
oh my God, I never imagined
216
:it could be that way.
217
:the whole notion of faith as a journey
in which one is constantly, encountering,
218
:richer answers, which generate more
questions, which generate, more
219
:answers, the quest for truth itself,
is every bit as important as, being
220
:able to nab little bits of it, as you
go along the preaching that has meant
221
:the most to me has been what I have
heard people, preachers open up biblical
222
:texts in a way that I had no idea.
223
:It could mean that much, have
those kinds of rich implications.
224
:I think the reason I enjoy teaching
preaching is that there is an initial,
225
:understandable, appropriate shyness.
226
:Who am I to speak for God?
227
:I don't have the ability.
228
:you connect with all sorts of,
call narratives in scripture.
229
:Moses, Jeremiah, Isaiah, Gideon,
Mary, how could this possibly be?
230
:find someone else, certainly not me,
but God, comes and says, Jeremiah,
231
:I have put my hand on your lips.
232
:I will tell you what to say,
you will be my mouthpiece.
233
:helping people in their own distinctive
ways to come into realizing how they can
234
:do that and how they can continue to grow.
235
:how they can learn from fellow
creatures because the act of
236
:preaching itself seems to be a solo
performance and a spectator sport.
237
:But the fact of the matter is, preachers
need each other as colleagues can learn
238
:from, support from grow with, each other.
239
:Forming communities of preachers who
gather as a community of practice.
240
:is a great joy, to me in some ways.
241
:as one other, homiletics professor,
whom I highly regard said I'm really
242
:like the bowl, which holds, all these
different, preachers in the same space.
243
:They interact with each other, teach
one another, and in the process I
244
:learned a great deal more about how I
can preach effectively in my own way.
245
:I discover new techniques, which can
be, evocative and illuminating, in
246
:terms of making suggestions to other
creatures, which is not simply a matter
247
:or ever, for that matter, a matter of
saying this was wrong, this was right.
248
:But this phrase, where exactly are
you hoping to take people with it?
249
:how does it relate to the idea earlier
in the sermon, which doesn't quite
250
:seem to square with that, both might
be true in a dialectical sort of way.
251
:The evolving of a preaching voice, like
the evolving of a sermon, is itself
252
:the spiritual journey, whether taken
by the individual preacher, whether
253
:taken by a group of, preachers in a
class or in, An ongoing commitment.
254
:it's just an exciting spiritual journey.
255
:Lauren Welch: It certainly is,
especially when you are teaching it.
256
:I can remember your energy.
257
:while you were teaching, which energized
all of us and we wanted to learn more.
258
:we wanted to learn to preach.
259
:what has surprised you the most?
260
:in your preaching journey
and your teaching journey,
261
:David Schlafer: I think on one hand
what has surprised me is, how difficult
262
:it can be to bridge gaps between
Christian community and local culture.
263
:It takes a tremendous amount of
thought, prayer, reflection to
264
:build those kinds of bridges.
265
:I'm always surprised when a
new bridge, reveals itself.
266
:it's a real struggle when you can't
seem to make connections so I suppose
267
:the surprise Has to do with being
persistent, but patient in the process
268
:of looking for connections that are
authentic, genuine not just simplistic,
269
:or superficial connections that, lead
to further growth and development.
270
:Jon Shematek: David, I'm thinking of
good sermons and not so good sermons
271
:that I've heard over my, lifetime.
272
:I'm pretty sure that the charism
or gift of preaching is not
273
:necessarily bestowed a hundred
percent on people that are ordained.
274
:David Schlafer: Oh, absolutely.
275
:some of the most effective preachers.
276
:Are ones that you have to listen to
because, people realize you're not
277
:being paid to say so, the whole notion
of evoking the preaching voices, of
278
:every member of the congregation,
is, is particularly important.
279
:What a good, ordained creature will do is.
280
:Stir up the gifts of communication and
connection, in members of the church
281
:community so that they can sustain and
grow, with each other, and spread the
282
:word, evangelism becomes not telling
you what you need to know and do,
283
:but engaging people in conversation
in which, insight is more fully.
284
:developed.,
285
:since Acts chapter two,
the, descent of Pentecost.
286
:It's often presented as though, when
the tongues of fire come upon, the
287
:disciples, they start spouting in
language that even they don't understand,
288
:that they've never heard before.
289
:at Pentecost.
290
:People from every nation would've
come, You can't mix in, the marketplace
291
:without picking up some words and
phrases from, folks you don't understand.
292
:my sense of, Pentecost is that,
Peter takes charge and he says,
293
:Who knows something of Parthian
who knows something of Medes?
294
:Go out there and engage in
conversation the best you can.
295
:what happens is, back and forth between
the languages, they come to understand
296
:the source of all their language, which is
the God whose, word, creates and convenes.
297
:Community.
298
:to your question.
299
:Yes, absolutely.
300
:non ordained preachers both in the pulpit,
but also by their life and witness, are
301
:really the most effective preachers.
302
:that the church has, I think.
303
:Jon Shematek: That's really
exciting to hear and I love it.
304
:I know that you've taught in a
lot of different sorts of venues
305
:and you will do, consulting or
meeting with, preachers regularly.
306
:do you do that sort of practice
with, non ordained people
307
:as well as ordained people?
308
:It certainly seems like that would be
a huge need and opportunity these days.
309
:David Schlafer: Yes, and the
way that often begins best is to
310
:gather, community of listeners.
311
:Who can become supportive of their parish,
preacher, pastor, priest, minister, to
312
:give them some skills for doing their
own deep listening so that they can
313
:give, effective, constructive feedback.
314
:To the, preacher, but also to extend the
spirited conversation of which that sermon
315
:is really simply, the starting point.
316
:and so done a fair number of
works with, number of workshops
317
:with small groups of, lay people.
318
:actually some of those, fairly, large
adult education kinds of, of settings.
319
:it's been a joy to help them realize
that they can not simply walk out
320
:and say, that was a good sermon, but
rather, here's what I heard you say.
321
:Here's what it leads me, to think,
here's the way in which, your sermon
322
:helped me, come to realize that.
323
:Here's where we could take this, the
ideas, the insights, the feelings,
324
:the focus, of the images of this
sermon and translate them more
325
:fully into life and the world.
326
:Jon Shematek: And what a joy that
would be as a preacher to have
327
:that sort of conversation after.
328
:No question.
329
:So David, sometimes we wait and see
what the Holy Spirit has in mind, and
330
:sometimes she tells us very clearly
and sometimes I say Lauren, I know
331
:you always have one final question.
332
:Lauren Welch: I always do.
333
:And David, you have shared your
passion, your love, of preaching
334
:and teaching preaching, to so many,
and you have empowered so many
335
:people to share the good news.
336
:What would you like to leave?
337
:Our listeners with today as a bit
of wisdom to take, to heart as they
338
:go out into the world and preach the
word, whether they're lay or ordained.
339
:David Schlafer: I think that, verse
of scripture, which says, the word
340
:of God is active and powerful,
sharper than a two-edged sword.
341
:able to separate between, bones
and marrow, is not, an image for
342
:cutting up, but rather getting
to the heart of the matter.
343
:I think it's terribly important in
a world when words are by and large
344
:in culture, one of two kinds trying
to sell you something, or trying to
345
:use words to bash people who are on
the other side of a political, fence.
346
:to be able to nurture a sense
of deep listening, careful
347
:speaking, respectful conversation.
348
:illuminating understanding so that, one
never has the last word, but the last
349
:word spoken is always the first word
for the next, round of conversation.
350
:you think about it.
351
:the way in which we experience
the most growth, the most
352
:intimacy, the most success is
when we interact with each other.
353
:In, a verbal way.
354
:And of course, it is possible to
engage in nonverbal communication,
355
:which often can speak very powerfully.
356
:and yet, we're in a time, it
seems to me when language is
357
:under a great deal of assault.
358
:To be able to try to bring people back to
its beauty, the beauty of language, the
359
:light that language sheds the connections
that are made at people integrate,
360
:their understandings with each other.
361
:it's a very powerful, thing to see
how destructive language can be.
362
:And alternatively how
creative language can be.
363
:I think what we are called to
do as responsible citizens, is,
364
:to combat the destructive force
of language, with a gracious.
365
:nurturing, empowering,
creative use of language.
366
:Jon Shematek: What a, powerful and timely
message for today and for days to come.
367
:David, this has been a joy.
368
:Thank you so much for being here today
and, giving us your words of wisdom
369
:and rekindling in me personally,
a wonderful, relationship and an
370
:excitement, for preaching the word of God.
371
:I just wanna personally thank you very
much for your time and your words today.
372
:David Schlafer: Just a joy
to be with both of you again.
373
:thanks so much.
374
:Lauren Welch: David, it has been a
delight to have you with us today.
375
:So thank you again And I
want to thank all who are.
376
:Watching and listening for
the gift of your time with us.
377
:Until next time, peace and blessings.
378
:Lynn Shematek: This episode
of Good News has been brought
379
:to you by Listening for Clues.
380
:For more podcasts, check out
our YouTube channel or our
381
:website listening for clues.com.